Deeply concerning wording (Human Intelligence?)


…what is this trying to say? that our intelligence is optional? that we are second? that human creativity is optional? that its all optional? do we even matter? whats wrong with you genuinely?

Also i turned AI off, why am i seeing this

this is pushing me, i think i might stop using gdevelop, youre all genuinely crazy

how can a group of (supposedly) 9 people be so tone deaf and inhuman?

also i refuse to talk about this in the main AI thread, its just noise. If you have actual concrete things to say, say them concisely, and read over it before sending it.

I mean, at least they didn’t say “continue with human ignorance” :stuck_out_tongue:

You won’t believe it bro… But those games are pre-made games. You don’t even need AI, yet it’s behind AI… Even though they could add it as a normal temple.

Since it’s pre-made, they could have cooked inside the engine like the other examples temple. If you want to use them “AI” temples now you must be online else you won’t get to use them too…

Imagine if every box of lego came with a little robot inside, that jumped out of the box as soon as a child opened the lid.

‘Just tell me what you want to make, and I will build it for you!’ it chirps

the child goes to touch the bricks.

‘Are you sure you want to continue with human intelligence?’ it barks. ‘I can build the Eiffel Tower, A black widow spider …I can even build a honey badger!’

‘ok’ says the child. ‘Could you build a honey badger.’

Bam - it’s there on the table, looking up at them, assembled in .1 seconds. Built so quickly that it was impossible to determine how it was done. The child runs off to show their mother what has been created.

Lego were under intense market pressure to head in this direction as K’nex at al had already done the same and Lego’s share price had started to flatline.

What is you product? Why do people use your product? What do they gain from using it?

Personally, as I slide off the wall of existence, i’m spending a couple of hours a day using it as game development entertains every corner of my cranium. I enjoy solving logic puzzles, i enjoy world building, i enjoy telling a story, i enjoy creating art and i enjoy creating music. I created too many errors when i coded as a teen due to inconsistent spelling and a flickering mental focus. GD shows me the error of my ways …there they are! magically highlighted in red!. It was a complete revelation …now I could make all those games that i dreamed of making as a child. ‘continue with human intelligence?’ …yes please!

So you seem to be really worked up over this, and I get it to an extent. While I don’t use or find use in any AI features in the engine I wanted to chime in because you seem to be seeing malice from the GDevelop.io team where there is none:

“Human Intelligence” is literally a tech industry (and education) term to indicate something done/learned/made by a person and not an LLM/generative system. It is not GDevelop specific, and it is being used to help you identify what was made by a person.

https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/research/blog/extending-human-intelligence-through-ai/

I think malice is the wrong word - I don’t think any of us view the team in this regard. I know that you’ve put at least 5 times the time and effort into GD that i have, and you must therefore care 5 times a strongly about its future…so phrases like ‘human intelligence’ need to be used by GD with the knowledge that most of GD’s users don’t read the sort of articles that you’ve shared above …and might possibly irk them a little.

It ain’t even about that, most of the times people don’t read articles cuz they (publishers) don’t just say the stuff straight. They be slanging the thing like it’s slipping out of their hands and same time trying to do backflip. Catch my meaning?

That’s why 90% of people when they want to learn something they watch a video on how to. And not go to documentation and read.

i understand, but it is inhuman in nature to say that. whether you care how it was worded or not, ai still shouldnt be first.